Best Metal Ice Cube Trays Consumer Reports

Are you tired of dealing with flimsy plastic ice cube trays that crack or break easily? Do you want to step up your cocktail game by using high-quality, long-lasting metal ice cube trays? Look no further because we have done the research and compiled a list of the best metal ice cube trays according to consumer reports. In this article, we will guide you through everything you need to know about metal ice cube trays, including how they work, their different types, benefits and common mistakes when using them. By the end of this post, you’ll be an expert on all things metal ice cubes! So sit back, relax and get ready for some icy fun!

Top 10 Metal Ice Cube Trays 

*Note: Score is based on our AI score (Editor’s choice and rating).

What Are Metal Ice Cube Trays?

Metal ice cube trays are, as their name suggests, made of metal. Unlike plastic trays that tend to be flimsy and easily breakable, metal ice cube trays are sturdier and more durable.

These trays come in a variety of shapes and sizes, ranging from classic rectangular or square designs to novelty shapes like stars or hearts. They also vary in capacity, with some holding just a few cubes while others can make dozens at once.

To use a metal ice cube tray, simply fill it with water and place it in the freezer until the water has frozen solid. Once the cubes have formed, you can pop them out by twisting the tray or running it briefly under warm water to loosen them up.

One benefit of using metal ice cube trays is that they tend to last longer than plastic ones. Metal is less likely to crack or become brittle over time compared to plastic materials used for making ice cube trays.

Another benefit is that they’re easy to clean- you can wash them by hand or put them in the dishwasher after each use without worrying about warping or damage caused by high temperatures.

Read more:  Best Wiithink Boomboxes Consumer Reports

How Do Metal Ice Cube Trays Work?

Metal ice cube trays work by providing a sturdy and durable container for freezing water into ice cubes. Unlike plastic or silicone trays, metal ones are less prone to cracking or breaking under pressure.

Most metal ice cube trays come in two parts: the tray itself and a separate lever that helps release the frozen cubes from their molds. To use them, simply fill the tray with water up to its capacity line, place it in your freezer, and wait until the water has frozen solid.

Once you’re ready to use your ice cubes, remove the tray from the freezer and let it thaw on your countertop for a few minutes. Then press down on the lever attached to each mold until they pop out of their slots.

One advantage of using metal ice cube trays is that they tend to produce larger and more uniform cubes than other types of trays. This is because metals conduct heat more efficiently than plastics or silicone, which means they can freeze water faster and more evenly.

Another benefit is that metal ice cube trays don’t absorb odors like some plastic ones do, making them ideal for storing in your freezer without worrying about any lingering smells tainting your drinks.

The Different Types of Metal Ice Cube Trays

When it comes to metal ice cube trays, there are a variety of types available on the market. Each type has its own unique features and benefits that cater to different needs and preferences.

The first type is the traditional style tray, which typically makes small rectangular ice cubes. These trays are made from durable stainless steel and come with removable dividers for easy release of individual cubes.

Another popular option is the silicone bottom tray, which features a flexible silicone base that allows for easy removal of ice cubes. This type also offers larger cube sizes than traditional trays.

For those who prefer crushed or shaved ice, a metal crusher tray may be the way to go. These trays often feature sharp blades that can crush or shave ice into various shapes and consistencies.

There are novelty-shaped metal ice cube trays available as well. From skulls to stars to animals, these fun options add an extra touch of personality to any drink presentation.

No matter what your preference may be, there is sure to be a metal ice cube tray out there that suits your specific needs and adds some flair to your beverages!

Read more:  Best Maglite Flashlight Bulbs Consumer Report

Factors to Consider Before Buying Metal Ice Cube Trays

Before buying a metal ice cube tray, there are several factors to consider that can greatly influence your decision. First and foremost, you should determine the size of cubes you want to create. Some trays make small cubes while others produce larger ones, so it’s essential to choose one that suits your preferences.

Another key factor is the durability of the tray. You’ll want one that won’t easily dent or warp over time as this can affect its ability to create well-formed ice cubes.

The material used in making the metal ice cube tray is another important consideration. Most are made with stainless steel or aluminum, which are both durable and rust-resistant materials that can withstand high temperatures without being damaged.

Additionally, take note of how many ice cubes each tray produces since some may only have a limited capacity per use. It’s also crucial to check if they come with lids for easy stacking and storage in your freezer.

Look at reviews from other consumers about their experience using different brands and models of metal ice cube trays before making a purchase. This can help ensure you get a product that meets both your expectations and budget while providing excellent value for money overall.

Benefits of Using Metal Ice Cube Trays

Using metal ice cube trays provides several benefits compared to using plastic or silicone ones. Metal is a durable material that can withstand wear and tear from regular use. This means that you won’t have to keep replacing your trays every few months.

The thermal conductivity of metal allows for faster freezing times compared to plastic or silicone trays. This leads to shorter waiting times when making ice cubes, which can be helpful if you’re in a rush.

Because they are made of metal, these ice cube trays are less likely to absorb odors and flavors from other items stored in the freezer. This ensures that your drinks will not be tainted with any unwanted tastes or smells.

Using metal ice cube trays is an environmentally friendly choice as they can be reused indefinitely without contributing to waste unlike disposable plastic options.

There are plenty of reasons why one should consider switching over to using metal ice cube trays instead of their plastic counterparts- durability, faster freezing times and environmental friendliness just being some of them!

Read more:  Best Desk Treadmill Consumer Reports

The Pros and Cons of Metal Ice Cube Trays

Metal ice cube trays are a popular choice among consumers due to their durability and longevity. However, like any product, they come with both pros and cons.

One of the biggest advantages of metal ice cube trays is their sturdiness. Unlike plastic options that can crack or warp over time, metal trays hold up well even after years of use. Additionally, because they’re made from non-porous materials, there’s less chance for bacteria buildup.

Another benefit is their ability to freeze water quickly. The cold temperature conductivity of metal allows it to freeze cubes faster than other materials such as silicone or plastic.

However, there are some downsides to using metal ice cube trays as well. One drawback is that they may give off a metallic taste when used for the first time or if not properly cleaned before initial use.

Furthermore, metal can be more difficult to clean compared to other types of materials. It’s important to wash them thoroughly after each use and avoid abrasives that could scratch the surface.

While there are pros and cons associated with using metal ice cube trays versus other materials such as silicone or plastic, many people choose them for their durability and quick-freezing capabilities.

Common Mistakes When Using Metal Ice Cube Trays

Using metal ice cube trays is a great way to keep your drinks cold and refreshing. However, there are some common mistakes that people make when using them. One of the most common mistakes is filling up the tray too much with water. This can cause the cubes to stick together and become difficult to remove.

Another mistake is not properly releasing the ice cubes from the tray. If you try to pry them out with a knife or other sharp object, you can damage both the tray and your utensil.

One thing that should always be avoided is putting hot liquids into metal ice cube trays. The sudden temperature change can cause warping or even cracking of the metal material.

It’s also important not to stack different types of metal ice cube trays on top of each other before freezing as this could cause some deformation in shape due to pressure build-up between one another.

Leaving used ice cubes in a dirty tray for too long without cleaning it thoroughly can lead to unwanted odors and flavors being transferred over time that may affect future uses.

By avoiding these common mistakes, you’ll ensure maximum longevity for your metal ice cube trays while keeping your drinks refreshingly cool!

Read more:  Best Xfl Mini Helmets Consumer Reports

How to Care for Your Metal Ice Cube Trays

Caring for your metal ice cube trays is essential to ensure their longevity and prevent any unwanted odors or bacteria growth. Here are some tips on how to properly take care of them.

Always wash your metal ice cube trays before first use with warm soapy water. Avoid using harsh detergents that may damage the tray’s surface. After each use, rinse the tray under running water to remove any leftover residue and dry it thoroughly.

If you notice any rust or discoloration on the tray’s surface, gently scrub it off with a soft sponge or cloth dipped in vinegar and baking soda solution. This mixture will help remove stains without damaging the metal.

To prevent odor buildup in your ice cubes, store them separately from other foods in sealed plastic bags or containers. You can also add a drop of lemon juice or white vinegar to each compartment before filling it up with water.

Avoid exposing your metal ice cube trays to extreme temperatures or direct sunlight as this could cause warping and deformation over time. Also, refrain from using sharp objects such as knives to pry out stubborn ice cubes as this may scratch the tray’s surface.

By following these simple care tips regularly, you can keep your metal ice cube trays looking new and serving up fresh-tasting drinks for years to come!

Installation and Maintenance Tips

Read more:  Best Whall Handheld Vacuum Consumer Report

When it comes to installing metal ice cube trays, there are a few things you should keep in mind. First and foremost, make sure you have the right tools for the job. This might include a screwdriver or drill depending on the type of tray you’re working with.

Once you’ve got your tools ready, carefully read through any installation instructions that come with your tray. Some models may be more complex than others and require specific steps to ensure they function properly.

In terms of maintenance, it’s important to clean your metal ice cube trays regularly to prevent any buildup or corrosion from forming. To do this, simply wash them with warm soapy water and dry thoroughly before using again.

If your trays start showing signs of wear and tear over time – such as rust or dents – consider replacing them rather than trying to repair them yourself. This will ensure that you always have effective ice cube trays on hand when needed without worrying about potential safety hazards or other issues down the line.

By taking good care of your metal ice cube trays from day one and following these simple installation tips along the way, you can enjoy crisp cold drinks all year round!

Tips For Setting Up Your Metal Ice Cube Trays

Setting up your metal ice cube trays can be a bit tricky if you’re not familiar with the process. Here are some tips to help make it easier:

First, wash your tray thoroughly before use. This will ensure that any residue or dirt is removed from the surface of the tray.

Next, fill each compartment with water just below the rim. It’s important not to overfill because this can cause spillage when transferring to the freezer.

Once filled, place your tray on an even surface in the freezer and leave it for several hours until frozen solid. For best results, leave overnight.

When ready to use, remove from freezer and gently twist or tap on a hard surface to loosen the cubes. Be careful not to force them out as this could damage both your tray and cubes.

If using for cocktails or drinks that require multiple ice cubes at once, consider investing in multiple trays so that you never run out!

By following these simple tips for setting up your metal ice cube trays, you’ll be able to enjoy perfectly formed ice every time without any fuss or hassle!

Read more:  Best YJ.GWL Carpet Consumer Report


FAQs or frequently asked questions are a common concern for any product, including metal ice cube trays. Here are some of the most commonly asked questions about metal ice cube trays.

One question is if metal ice cube trays can be put in the dishwasher. The answer here is that it depends on the specific tray and its material. While some may be dishwasher safe, others may not be recommended for use in a dishwasher due to potential damage from high temperatures or harsh detergents.

Another frequent question concerns how long it takes for water to freeze in a metal ice cube tray. This largely depends on various factors such as freezer temperature, water volume, and size of the cubes themselves among other things.

Some individuals also wonder whether they need to oil their metal trays before use. In general, this isn’t necessary since most new models come with a non-stick surface built-in or have an easy release mechanism that makes removing frozen cubes easier.

People often ask whether it’s better to buy silicone or plastic rather than metallic options when choosing an ice tray; however, each option has its own benefits and drawbacks depending on personal preferences.

These answers should help you make informed decisions about using your own best Metal Ice Cube Trays!


Metal ice cube trays are a fantastic addition to any kitchen. They offer several benefits over plastic or silicone options, including durability and the ability to create large, crystal-clear cubes that won’t dilute your drinks. When shopping for metal ice cube trays, be sure to consider factors such as size, ease of use, and design.

Remember that proper care and maintenance can help ensure your metal ice cube trays last for years to come. Follow our tips on installation and maintenance for best results.

Investing in high-quality metal ice cube trays is a smart decision that will elevate your home bar game and impress your guests. So go ahead – treat yourself to the best metal ice cube tray on the market today!

Rate this post

Leave a Comment