Best Ice Cream Makers Consumer Reports

Best ice cream makers consumer reports

There are a lot of different factors you need to consider when purchasing an ice cream maker. With all the different brands and models available, it can be hard to determine which one is right for you. In this blog post, we will outline the three best ice cream makers on the market and what makes them stand out from the competition. We’ll also provide some tips on how to choose the right one for your needs. So, whether you’re in the market for your first ice cream maker or looking to upgrade, read on for our top picks!

Top 10 Best Ice Cream Makers

*Note: Score is based on our AI score (Editor’s choice and rating).

What is an ice cream makers?

Ice cream makers are machines that freeze and churn a mixture of milk, cream, sugar, and flavorings to create ice cream. There are both commercial and home ice cream makers available. Commercial ice cream makers can produce large quantities of ice cream at a time, while home ice cream makers are smaller and more affordable for the average consumer. The process of making ice cream in an ice cream maker is relatively simple.

Factors to consider before buying ice cream makers

Ice cream makers are a great addition to any kitchen. You can make your own ice cream in just minutes, and it’s healthier, too. However, buying an ice cream maker can be confusing. There are many different models with different features and price points, which makes it hard to know what is best for you. Here are some things you should consider when buying an ice cream maker:

Read more:  Best Midi Keyboards Consumer Reports

Ease of Cleaning

If you’re the kind of person who likes to keep things clean, you’ll want to consider how difficult it will be for you to clean your machine after use. Some machines have parts that are dishwasher-safe, so you don’t have to worry about hand-washing any pieces—but others may require more work from you to keep them sanitary and safe for next time.


The capacity of your ice cream maker determines how much ice cream or frozen treat you can make at any given time. Consider how much space you have in your freezer when choosing one with a large capacity. If your freezer has limited space, buy a machine with a lower capacity so it won’t take up too much room. For example, if you only want to make four servings per batch, get an ice cream maker that can make four servings at a time instead of eight or more servings at once.

Space-saving design

If you’re in a small apartment or condo, you’ll want to look for an ice cream maker that doesn’t take up too much space in your freezer. This means a model that’s small enough to fit in your freezer without taking up too much room, or one that has interchangeable parts that can be stored elsewhere when not in use (for example, the bowl of an electric model might be stored on your countertop).

Customer Service

How easy is it to reach customer service if something goes wrong with your purchase? Do they have a phone number on their website or just email? Are they friendly and helpful when responding? Do they respond quickly or take forever? If something goes wrong with your machine, how easy will it be for them to help you out?

Ease of Use

You want something that comes with instructions that are easy to read and understand so that even someone who has never used an appliance like this before can figure out how everything works quickly without having to spend hours reading through manuals or calling customer service representatives who aren’t able to answer all your questions right away either! This way too!


When comparing different ice cream makers, it is important to consider how long each model takes to make ice cream. Some models take up to an hour to prepare ice cream while others can be ready in as little as 20 minutes. The time it takes for an ice cream maker depends on the amount of ingredients that need to be added, but the more expensive models are faster than their less expensive counterparts.


The paddle is one of the most important parts of your ice cream maker. It’s what takes the mixture from the bowl and pushes it through the freezing mechanism, where it freezes into delicious ice cream. Some paddles are made of plastic, but others are stainless steel or aluminum alloy. If you’re going to be using your ice cream maker in a commercial setting, you should opt for stainless steel or aluminum alloy. These materials will not break down as quickly as plastic would under heavy use.

Read more:  Best Cotton Car Covers Consumer Report


If noise bothers you when trying to relax in your own home, make sure that any ice cream maker you choose does not emit loud noises during use! This will ensure peace and quiet during cooking sessions so that you can enjoy making delicious treats with family members or friends without having to worry about disturbing others who may be sleeping nearby or working inside their own homes nearby yours.


Plastic is cheap and lightweight but can be difficult to clean; stainless steel provides durability but doesn’t always come in colors; glass has great insulation properties but can break if dropped onto hard surfaces like concrete or tile floors; aluminum conducts heat well so it transfers faster than other materials would but may cause discoloration over time if exposed directly to sunlight (like aluminum foil).


What size batches do you want to make? This will determine how big of an ice cream maker you need. If you plan on making large batches and giving them away as gifts or having parties where people can help themselves to scoops of your delicious homemade ice cream, then a larger capacity ice cream maker is ideal. If you just want to make a couple of small batches for yourself and your family each week, then a smaller model will do just fine!


You want your machine to last if possible so that you don’t have to spend money on a new one every year or two! Make sure that your chosen machine comes with a warranty that covers any defects or malfunctions that may occur during normal use. If possible, look at the manufacturer’s website to see if they offer any additional warranty options such as extended coverage or accidental damage protection.


Some models are sleek and modern while others are more traditional looking. If you plan to keep your machine out in the open, then it is important that it blends well with other kitchen appliances so as not to take away from the decor of your home. On the other hand, if you plan on keeping it hidden away underneath cabinets or behind closed doors then size may be more important than appearance because no one will see it anyway!


The timer is a very important factor because it allows you to set the time for your ice cream to be done, and when it reaches that time, it will automatically shut off. This means that you don’t have to worry about checking on your ice cream every now and then to see if it is ready. In addition, some timers have alarms so that they can alert you when your ice cream is ready. However, there are some models that do not have timers at all, so make sure you choose one with this feature if necessary.

Read more:  Best X-Narrow Clog Consumer Reports


Ice cream makers come in a variety of designs, including countertop and portable models. Countertop models are larger and heavier than portable models, but they tend to be easier to use and have larger capacities. Portable models are more convenient for making smaller batches of ice cream at home or on the go. They’re also typically less expensive than countertop models. If you plan on making large batches of ice cream regularly, then you might want to consider a more powerful model with a larger capacity. On the other hand, if you only want to make small amounts of ice cream at home or while traveling, then a smaller model will suffice.


You may have heard of some brands more than others, but it’s always good to do your own research before making a final decision. For example, even if a brand is known for making high-quality products, this does not necessarily mean that every product they make will also be high quality. On the other hand, if you see a brand that has produced many different types of products over time and each one has received positive reviews from customers then chances are their ice cream maker will be worth buying too!


Another important consideration is how fast the ice cream maker works. If it takes too long to make your favorite frozen treat, then it won’t be worth buying! You should also consider how many batches of ice cream it can make in one session before needing to be cleaned out or refilled with more ingredients. Some models will also have interchangeable bowls for different sizes and shapes of ice cream molds or cups so that you can make multiple types of desserts in one sitting without having to stop halfway through for cleaning purposes (which would just be super annoying!).

Benefits of ice cream makers

Ice cream makers also offer other benefits:

-They’re easy to use. All you need to do is put your ingredients in the bowl, turn on the machine, and wait for it to be done!

-Ice cream makers are inexpensive. While some of them may be more expensive than others, they’re still affordable compared to buying ice cream from the store. Plus, they’re worth every penny if you love making ice cream as much as we do!

-You can control what goes into your ice cream by making it yourself. You know exactly what went into your batch—no preservatives or artificial colors here!

-You’ll never have an excuse not to make ice cream again because it’s so easy with an ice cream maker! Whether you want to make a small batch for yourself or a large one for a party, you can do it with an ice cream maker.

Read more:  Best Bunn Bulk Commercial Coffee Grinder Consumer Report

Pros and Cons of ice cream makers


-Ice cream makers are not expensive, and they can be found at many retail stores.

-Ice cream makers are easy to use, and they make making delicious desserts a breeze.

-Ice cream makers are great for people who live alone or with only one other person. They can serve as a great way to create new desserts without having to make a whole lot of extra food that may go bad before it is all eaten.


-Ice Cream makers can be loud when in use. This means that you may need to use ear protection while making ice cream if you live with other people or have neighbors who do not understand the importance of noise reduction when enjoying their favorite treat!

-Ice cream makers can be messy. Be sure to have plenty of paper towels on hand to clean up any spills!

-Ice cream makers require some amount of preparation time. This means that you will need to plan if you want to enjoy a delicious dessert at the end of the day.

Types of ice cream makers

When it comes to making your own ice cream, you have several options.

Mixer Attachments

If you have an electric mixer, you can use a special attachment to make your own frozen desserts. This method is typically used for making ice cream cakes and other frozen treats that require multiple freezing stages. These attachments are not as efficient at making ice cream than the other methods, but they are very convenient because they use kitchen appliances that many people already own.

Compressor Ice Cream Makers

If you want to make large amounts of ice cream quickly and efficiently, then a compressor ice cream maker may be right for you. These machines use refrigeration technology to freeze the ingredients quickly and evenly so that the resulting product is creamy and smooth. The downside of compressor machines is that they are expensive and noisy compared to other types of machines. However, if you’re looking for professional results at home, then this may be the best option for you!

Freezer Bowl Ice Cream Makers

One way to make delicious homemade ice cream without having to buy another appliance or spend money on electricity is by using a freezer bowl machine. These devices are very affordable and easy-to-use; however, they don’t produce quite as much volume as the other methods. Additionally, the freezer bowl must be completely frozen before use, so it’s important to plan if you want to make ice cream with one of these machines.

Common mistakes when using ice cream makers

When using an ice cream maker, there are a few mistakes you can make that will ruin your ice cream.

Read more:  Best Scotsman Ice Makers Consumer Reports

1) Not chilling the bowl and ingredients enough before beginning to mix the ingredients. This is especially true if you’re using a hand-crank machine—you want to get everything cold so that it’s ready to freeze when you start mixing.

2) Not scraping down the sides of the bowl often enough while mixing. This is important because if your spatula doesn’t scrape all around, it can leave large chunks of unmixed ingredients at the bottom of your bowl, which will not freeze well.

3) Overmixing. This is an easy mistake to make if you’re using a hand-crank machine: just keep going! But it’s worth keeping an eye on the clock so that you don’t overdo it. Overmixing can make your ice cream grainy.

4) Not adding enough salt. This might seem like a strange ingredient to add, but salt helps to lower the freezing point of the mixture, which means your ice cream will be creamier and smoother.

5) Adding too many mix-ins. Mix-ins are delicious, but they can also make your ice cream heavy and dense if you use too many of them. Stick to 1 or 2 mix-ins per batch so that your ice cream is still light and fluffy.

How to use ice cream makers?

If you want to use an ice cream maker, there are a few steps you need to follow.

First, make sure that you have all the necessary ingredients. You’ll need sweetened condensed milk, egg yolks, and vanilla extract. You can also add some salt if you want to give your ice cream a salty taste.

Second, pre-freeze your ice cream maker bowl for at least 8 hours before making the ice cream. This will ensure that your machine is ready when you need it.

Third, pour the sweetened condensed milk into your machine’s bowl and set it on low speed for about 20 minutes (or until it’s thick enough). Then add the egg yolks and vanilla extract and continue mixing until they’re fully incorporated into the mixture. If you want to add salt, do so now—you’ll be able to taste it right away when mixed with the other ingredients!

Fourth is optional: if you’d like to add any extras like marshmallows or chocolate chips now (or even before adding them), go ahead! Just make sure everything gets evenly distributed throughout the mix before continuing with step 5 below.

Fifth, once everything is mixed, it’s time to start churning the ice cream! Turn your machine on and let it do its thing until the mixture has thickened and turned into delicious ice cream. This usually takes about 15-20 minutes.

Last, once the ice cream is ready, you can either eat it right away or store it in your freezer for later. If you decide to store it, make sure to put it in an airtight container so that it doesn’t get freezer burn. And that’s all there is to making homemade ice cream—it’s not as difficult as you might think! Give it a try sometime and see for yourself.

Read more:  Best Ankle Strap Clog Consumer Reports

FAQs about Best ice cream makers consumer reports

What happens if you churn ice cream too long?

When you churn ice cream too long, it can be damaged in a few different ways.

First, it can lose its texture. The longer you churn ice cream, the more air gets whipped into it and the less creamy and smooth your final product will be.

Another problem is that if you churn too long, the fats in your mix can separate from the water. This will cause your ice cream to be grainy and unpleasant to eat—and even worse for your teeth!

Finally, when you churn for too long, it can start to melt! This means that once you take your ice cream out of the machine and let it sit out on the counter for a few minutes before serving (which is a common practice), much of it will have melted away by then.

How do you keep ice cream from getting hard?

Keeping ice cream from getting hard is a common problem for many people. Luckily, there are several ways to keep ice cream from getting hard.

First, you should always store your ice cream in a freezer that has been turned off for at least 24 hours. This will allow the temperature of the freezer to reach its maximum coldness before you store your ice cream.

Second, make sure that you do not store your ice cream too close to the door of the freezer. If the door is left open too often or too long, it can reduce the overall temperature of your freezer and cause your ice cream to become hard.

Finally, if you have a stainless-steel container or bowl in which you are storing your ice cream, make sure that it always remains clean and dry. If there is any moisture present on its surface when it meets the frozen treat inside, then this moisture will cause it to melt faster than normal and become soft again before you want it too!

Conclusion – Best ice cream makers consumer reports

The best ice cream makers can churn out delicious batches of your favorite frozen dessert in just minutes. Whether you’re looking for a machine that does all the work for you or one that lets you customize every step of the process, we’ve got you covered. We’ve put together a comprehensive list of the top ten best ice cream makers on the market today, so read on to find the perfect fit for your needs. Do you have a favorite brand or model? Let us know in the comments below!

Rate this post

Leave a Comment