Best Polystyrene Ice Cube Trays Consumer Reports

Are you tired of dealing with messy, flimsy ice cube trays that just won’t do the job right? Look no further than polystyrene ice cube trays! These sturdy and reliable kitchen essentials are a game changer when it comes to keeping your drinks cool and refreshing. In this article, we’ll dive into everything you need to know about choosing the best polystyrene ice cube trays for your needs. From different types to factors to consider before buying, we’ve got you covered. So sit back, grab a cold drink (with perfectly formed cubes, of course), and let’s get started!

Top 10 Polystyrene Ice Cube Trays

*Note: Score is based on our AI score (Editor’s choice and rating).

What Are Polystyrene Ice Cube Trays?

Polystyrene ice cube trays are just what they sound like – durable, reusable trays that make it easy to create perfectly shaped ice cubes. These trays are typically made from polystyrene plastic, a material known for its strength and resistance to cracking or breaking over time.

One of the key benefits of using polystyrene ice cube trays is their ability to produce consistent, high-quality ice each and every time. Because these trays are designed specifically for freezing water into cube shapes, you can count on them to deliver reliable results with minimal fuss.

Another advantage of polystyrene ice cube trays is their versatility. While some models might be geared more towards making standard-sized cubes, others may offer options for larger or smaller sizes depending on your needs.

If you’re looking for an easy way to keep your drinks cool without having to deal with messy or inefficient methods like filling up bags with loose ice cubes or using disposable plastic molds that easily crack and break apart after a few uses, then investing in a set of quality polystyrene ice cube trays could be worth considering!

How Do Polystyrene Ice Cube Trays Work?

Polystyrene ice cube trays are a common household item that most people have used at least once in their lives. But have you ever wondered how they actually work?

The process is quite simple, really. Polystyrene is a type of plastic that has good insulation properties and can withstand low temperatures without breaking down or warping. When filled with water and placed in the freezer, the polystyrene tray will freeze the water into ice cubes due to its insulating properties.

As the water freezes, it expands and fills up each individual compartment of the tray to create perfectly shaped ice cubes. Once frozen solid, users can simply twist or tap on the bottom of the tray to release each cube from its mold.

One important thing to note about using polystyrene ice cube trays is that they should be properly cleaned before use as any dirt or residue left behind could affect both taste and quality of your ice cubes.

While polystyrene may not be as eco-friendly as other materials such as silicone or stainless steel, it remains a popular choice for many households due to its affordability and durability when compared to other options available on market.

Read more:  Best Miele Washing Machines Consumer Reports

The Different Types of Polystyrene Ice Cube Trays

Polystyrene ice cube trays come in a variety of shapes and sizes, each with their own unique features. The classic tray is the standard rectangular shape, but there are also circular and square trays available for those who prefer different shapes.

For those who want to make larger ice cubes or even sphere-shaped ones, there are specialty molds available that can create these types of ice. Some polystyrene ice cube trays also include lids to prevent spills in your freezer while others have flexible silicone bases which allow you to easily pop out the cubes without breaking them.

One popular type of polystyrene ice cube tray is the stackable design. These trays can be stacked on top of each other for easy storage and organization in your freezer. There are also novelty designs such as animal shapes or even Lego-inspired molds that add a fun twist to your drinks.

If you’re someone who enjoys making flavored drinks or cocktails at home, then consider investing in an infuser tray. These specialized polystyrene trays have compartments where you can place herbs, fruits or other ingredients which will infuse into the water as it freezes creating delicious flavor combinations.

No matter what type of polystyrene ice cube tray you choose, ensure it fits within your needs and preferences when it comes to size, shape and functionality so that you always have perfectly shaped and sized iced treats ready whenever needed!

Read more:  Best Portable Pellet Grill Consumer Reports

Benefits of Using Polystyrene Ice Cube Trays

Polystyrene ice cube trays have a lot of benefits that make them stand out from other types of ice cube trays. One benefit is their durability, as polystyrene is known for being long-lasting and able to withstand wear and tear. This means you won’t have to replace your ice cube tray often.

Another advantage of polystyrene ice cube trays is that they are easy to clean. They don’t absorb odor or flavor, so you can simply rinse them with water after each use and they will be ready for the next round of freezing.

Additionally, polystyrene ice cube trays offer a higher level of customization than other types of ice cube trays. You can find them in various shapes and sizes, making it easier to create unique drinks or cocktails.

Furthermore, using polystyrene ice cube trays allows you to save space in your freezer since they are stackable. This makes it more convenient when storing multiple containers at once.

If you’re environmentally conscious, choosing polystyrene over plastic could be a better option as it’s recyclable. Therefore, by choosing this type of material for your kitchen essentials like an ice-cube tray can make a small impact on reducing waste in landfills while enjoying its benefits mentioned above

The Pros and Cons of Polystyrene Ice Cube Trays

Polystyrene ice cube trays are a popular choice for those who want to make their own ice cubes at home. However, like any product, there are both pros and cons to using them.

One of the main advantages of polystyrene ice cube trays is that they are lightweight and easy to handle. They also come in different shapes and sizes, allowing users to customize their ice cubes according to their preferences.

Another benefit is that polystyrene is an excellent insulator, which means it can keep your drinks cold for longer periods. Polystyrene trays also freeze faster than other materials such as silicone or metal.

On the downside, some people may find that polystyrene has a chemical smell when first used, which could potentially affect the taste of the ice cubes. Additionally, repeated use could cause wear and tear on the tray’s surface over time.

Furthermore, since polystyrene is not biodegradable or recyclable in most areas, it can contribute to environmental pollution if not disposed of properly after use.

While there are certainly pros and cons associated with using polystyrene ice cube trays – ultimately it comes down to personal preference.

Read more:  Best Magic Baking Sheet Consumer Reports

Common Mistakes When Using Polystyrene Ice Cube Trays

Using polystyrene ice cube trays may seem like a simple task, but there are some common mistakes that people make when using them. One of the most common mistakes is not properly cleaning the tray before use. The tray should be washed with warm water and soap to remove any dirt or debris.

Another mistake is overfilling the tray with water. This can cause the cubes to stick together and make it difficult to remove them from the tray. It’s best to fill each compartment only ¾ full.

Not allowing enough time for freezing is another mistake many people make. It’s important to leave enough time for the water in each compartment to freeze completely, which usually takes around four hours.

Trying to remove all of the ice cubes at once by twisting or bending can also damage or break the tray. Instead, gently push on one end of each compartment until they pop out individually.

Leaving unused cubes in the tray without covering them can lead to freezer burn and an unpleasant taste in your drinks later on. Always transfer unused cubes into an airtight container before returning them back into your freezer.

By avoiding these common mistakes when using polystyrene ice cube trays, you will ensure that you have perfectly formed ice every time!

How to Care for Your Polystyrene Ice Cube Trays

Read more:  Best Impecca Microwave Consumer Report

To ensure the longevity of your polystyrene ice cube trays, proper care and maintenance is necessary. Here are some tips on how to take care of them:

Avoid using abrasive materials when cleaning your trays as this can damage the surface and cause scratches. Instead, use a soft cloth or sponge with mild soap and warm water.

Never place your polystyrene ice cube trays in the dishwasher as they may warp or crack due to high temperatures. It’s best to wash them by hand with gentle soap and lukewarm water.

Make sure you dry your trays thoroughly after washing them. Leaving them damp can lead to bacterial growth which could affect the quality of your ice cubes.

Always store your polystyrene ice cube trays in a cool and dry place away from direct sunlight or heat sources. This will prevent warping or cracking over time.

By following these simple tips for caring for your polystyrene ice cube trays, you’ll be able to enjoy perfectly shaped ice cubes every time without worrying about damaging or replacing them too soon!

Installation and Maintenance Tips

When it comes to installing and maintaining your polystyrene ice cube trays, there are a few tips that can help ensure they last as long as possible. Make sure you read the instructions carefully before attempting to install or use the trays.

To install them, simply fill each compartment with water and place it in the freezer until frozen solid. Once frozen, twist or flex the tray slightly to loosen the cubes and remove them from the tray.

In terms of maintenance, be sure to clean your polystyrene ice cube trays regularly with warm soapy water and rinse thoroughly before reuse. Avoid using abrasive cleaners or scrubbers as this can damage the surface of the tray.

It’s also important to store your polystyrene ice cube trays properly when not in use. Keep them away from direct sunlight or heat sources which could cause warping or cracking over time.

By following these simple installation and maintenance tips for your polystyrene ice cube trays, you’ll be able to enjoy perfectly chilled drinks all year round!

Read more:  Best Relieve Back Pain Mattress Consumer Report

Tips For Setting Up Your Polystyrene Ice Cube Trays

Setting up polystyrene ice cube trays is a straightforward process that requires little effort, but following a few tips can help you get the most out of your purchase.

Before filling your tray with water, make sure it’s clean and dry. Leftover debris or moisture can cause the cubes to stick together or become discolored. A simple rinse under warm water should do the trick.

Consider using filtered water instead of tap water for clearer ice cubes. Tap water often contains minerals and impurities that can affect the taste and appearance of your ice.

Fill each compartment with just enough water to cover the top without overflowing. Overfilling could cause spillage in your freezer while also making it difficult to remove individual cubes.

Once filled with water, carefully place the tray on an even surface in your freezer. Avoid tilting or shaking it too much as this may cause uneven freezing resulting in misshapen cubes.

Following these simple tips will ensure that you get perfectly formed ice cubes every time from your polystyrene ice cube trays!


FAQs or frequently asked questions are a common feature of any product, including polystyrene ice cube trays. Here we’ve compiled some of the most commonly asked questions about these products.

– What is the best material for ice cube trays?
Polystyrene is one of the best materials for ice cube trays because it’s non-toxic and can withstand freezing temperatures without cracking or breaking.

– Are polystyrene ice cube trays dishwasher safe?
Yes, most polystyrene ice cube trays are dishwasher safe. However, it’s always best to check with the manufacturer before putting them in the dishwasher.

– Can I use my polystyrene ice cube tray to freeze other liquids besides water?
Absolutely! You can freeze any liquid you’d like in your polystyrene ice cube tray, including juice, coffee, tea, and even cocktails!

– How long does it take for water to freeze in a polystyrene ice cube tray?
It typically takes around 2-4 hours for water to fully freeze in a standard polystyrene ice cube tray.

– Can I stack multiple layers of filled polystyrene ice cubes on top of each other while they’re still freezing?
No. It’s not recommended that you stack multiple layers until after all cubes have frozen solid as this will cause uneven freezing and may result in melted spots at the bottom layer.

These are just some examples of FAQs related to using and caring for your polystyrene Ice Cube Trays. If you have more specific questions regarding its usage or maintenance feel free to refer from its manual or contact customer support.

Read more:  Best Noise Canceling Headphones For Snowboarding Consumer Reports


Choosing the best polystyrene ice cube trays can be a daunting task, but with careful consideration of the factors mentioned above and proper maintenance, you can enjoy perfectly shaped and frozen ice cubes every time. Keep in mind that different types of polystyrene ice cube trays work differently, so it’s essential to understand your needs before selecting one.

Moreover, always read customer reviews on reputable websites such as Consumer Reports to ensure you get value for your money. Remember also to store the trays correctly and follow the manufacturer’s instructions for maximum longevity.

If you want convenience and quality when making iced drinks or cocktails at home, then investing in high-quality polystyrene ice cube trays is an excellent decision. Not only will they save you money over time compared to buying bags of pre-made ice cubes; they’ll also elevate your drink-making experience by providing perfectly shaped and frozen cubes every time.

Rate this post