Best Plastic Ice Cube Trays Consumer Reports

Do you love to chill with an icy cold drink on a hot summer day? Or maybe you’re into making fancy cocktails for your guests at dinner parties? Whatever the reason, having perfectly shaped and sized ice cubes can make all the difference. That’s where plastic ice cube trays come in! In this article, we’ll be exploring everything you need to know about plastic ice cube trays – from how they work and their different types, to factors to consider before buying them and common mistakes people make when using them. So sit back, relax, grab a cool drink (with some perfect ice cubes of course!) and let’s dive into the world of plastic ice cube trays.

Top 10 Plastic Ice Cube Trays

*Note: Score is based on our AI score (Editor’s choice and rating).

What Are Plastic Ice Cube Trays?

Plastic ice cube trays are a common household item used for making ice cubes. They come in various shapes, sizes and colors and are usually made of food-grade plastic material. The primary purpose of these trays is to freeze water into perfectly shaped and sized ice cubes that can be used for drinks, cocktails or other frozen treats.

These trays have compartments with different shapes that allow you to create a variety of interesting designs such as stars, hearts, spheres, diamonds and more. Most plastic ice cube trays hold around 12-16 cubes per tray but some models can hold up to 32 or more.

One of the benefits of plastic ice cube trays is their affordability – they’re relatively cheap compared to other types like silicone or metal ones. Another advantage is their durability; they’re resistant to breaking if dropped on the floor.

However, it’s important to note that not all plastic ice cube trays are created equal. Some may contain harmful chemicals like BPA (Bisphenol A), which has been linked to health issues when ingested over time.

Plastic ice cube trays offer an easy way to make perfect icy cold drinks at home without having to spend too much money or effort.

Read more:  Best High Lift Jack Stands Consumer Reports

How Do Plastic Ice Cube Trays Work?

Plastic ice cube trays are simple yet efficient kitchen tools that allow you to make ice cubes easily. Most plastic ice cube trays come in a standard rectangular shape with small compartments for water.

To use it, simply fill each compartment with water and place the tray in the freezer. The water freezes and turns into solid cubes over time. Once frozen, you can remove the tray from the freezer, twist or flex it slightly to release the cubes from their molds, and voila! You have freshly made ice cubes ready to go.

One thing to note is that plastic ice cube trays work best when filled only about 2/3 of the way full. This leaves enough space for expansion as the water freezes so that your tray won’t crack or break due to pressure buildup.

Another important factor in how plastic ice cube trays work is how quickly they freeze. If your freezer runs too cold or you leave your tray in for too long, it can cause issues such as cloudy-looking or misshapen cubes.

Using plastic ice cube trays is an easy and convenient way to always ensure you have fresh ice on hand for all your beverages needs.

The Different Types of Plastic Ice Cube Trays

Plastic ice cube trays come in a variety of shapes and sizes, making them ideal for different purposes. The most common types are the traditional rectangular shape that produces 12 to 16 cubes per tray, but there are also specialized molds available that create unique shapes like spheres or hearts.

For those who prefer larger ice cubes, there are trays with fewer compartments designed for this purpose. These types of trays typically produce four to six large cubes that melt slower than their smaller counterparts – perfect for whiskey drinkers.

If you’re looking to add some fun to your drinks, consider novelty ice cube trays shaped like animals or letters. These can be great conversation starters at parties or just a fun addition to family dinners.

Another option is silicone ice cube trays which offer greater flexibility when it comes time to remove the cubes. They’re also dishwasher safe and less likely to crack than their plastic counterparts.

The type of plastic ice cube tray you choose should depend on your personal preferences and needs. With so many options available on the market today, there’s sure to be one that fits perfectly into your life!

Read more:  Best Popblossom Ice Cube Trays Consumer Reports

Factors to Consider Before Buying Plastic Ice Cube Trays

Before buying a plastic ice cube tray, there are several factors to consider that will ensure you get the best product for your needs.

Consider the size of the tray and how many cubes it can make at once. If you frequently entertain guests or have a large family, then opting for a larger tray with more capacity may be ideal.

Think about the shape of the cubicles and whether they suit your preferences. Some plastic ice cube trays come in unique shapes such as spheres or diamonds which can add an extra touch of flair to your drinks.

Another important factor is durability and material quality. Look for trays made from durable materials that won’t crack or break easily over time.

Ease of use is also critical – make sure you choose a tray that’s easy to fill without spilling water everywhere. Additionally, check if it’s dishwasher safe before purchasing it

Consider any additional features like lids or stackable designs which could save space in your freezer.

By considering these factors before making your purchase decision, you’ll end up with a high-quality plastic ice cube tray perfect for all occasions!

Benefits of Using Plastic Ice Cube Trays

Using plastic ice cube trays has several benefits that make them a popular choice for both home and commercial use. One of the biggest advantages is their affordability – they are much cheaper than other types of ice makers, making it easier to replace them if needed.

Another benefit is their flexibility in terms of shape and size. Plastic ice cube trays come in different shapes and sizes, allowing you to choose the perfect one for your needs. Some even have unique features like silicone bottoms that make it easy to remove the cubes without breaking them.

Plastic ice cube trays are also very easy to clean since they can be washed by hand or put in a dishwasher. This makes maintenance effortless, saving time and effort compared to other types of ice makers.

In addition, because plastic is such a durable material, these ice cube trays last longer than others, meaning you won’t need to replace them as often.

Using plastic ice cube trays reduces waste since there’s no need for disposable cups or bags when making your own homemade iced drinks at home or on-the-go.

The benefits of using plastic ice cube trays make them an excellent choice for anyone looking for affordable convenience with minimal environmental impact.

Read more:  Best Aeropro Paint Sprayers Consumer Report

The Pros and Cons of Plastic Ice Cube Trays

Plastic ice cube trays have become an essential item in most kitchens. They are affordable, easy to use, and come in different shapes and sizes. However, like everything else, they have their pros and cons.

One of the biggest advantages of plastic ice cube trays is that they are so easy to use. All you need to do is fill them with water, put them in the freezer for a few hours, and voila! You’ve got yourself some ice cubes.

Another advantage is that these trays come in various shapes and sizes; from traditional square-shaped moulds to novelty designs such as hearts or stars. This gives you more options when it comes to making drinks or cocktails.

However, one disadvantage of plastic ice cube trays is that they can be flimsy and prone to cracking over time due to repeated freezing cycles. Moreover, if not handled correctly while filling up with water or removing the cubes from the tray after freezing may result in spillages or breakage.

Another downside associated with plastic ice cube trays is their durability compared to other materials such as silicone or metal which last longer. In addition ,most plastic models tend not seal well enough causing leakage problems during transport from sink-to-freezer

Though there are many benefits that outweigh the negatives when it comes down selecting suitable Ice Cube Trays for your kitchen needs .

Read more:  Best Luminary Global First Aid Kit Consumer Reports

Common Mistakes When Using Plastic Ice Cube Trays

Using plastic ice cube trays may seem like a simple task, but there are some common mistakes people make when using them. One of the most frequent errors is overfilling the trays with water. This can cause the cubes to stick together and become difficult to remove.

Another mistake people make is not allowing enough time for the cubes to freeze properly. Rushing this process can result in soft or unevenly frozen ice cubes that melt quickly and dilute your drinks.

It’s also important not to twist or bend the tray while trying to remove the ice cubes. Doing so could damage both the tray and your freezer.

Some people forget to clean their plastic ice cube trays regularly, which can lead to unpleasant tastes or odors in their ice cubes. To prevent this from happening, it’s best to wash your trays after every use with warm water and soap.

Storing the plastic ice cube trays improperly can cause them to crack or break over time. It’s recommended that you store them on a flat surface rather than stacking them on top of each other.

By avoiding these common mistakes, you’ll be able enjoy perfectly shaped and refreshing homemade ice cubes every time!

Tips For Setting Up Your Plastic Ice Cube Trays

Setting up your plastic ice cube trays can be a quick and easy process if you follow some simple tips. First, make sure that the tray is clean before filling it with water. This will ensure that the ice cubes are free of any dirt or debris.

Next, slowly pour water into each compartment of the tray until they are approximately ¾ full. Avoid overfilling as this can lead to spillage when placing in the freezer.

It’s also important to level out the water in each compartment before placing them in the freezer. This helps prevent uneven freezing and ensures perfectly shaped ice cubes every time.

When placing your filled tray in the freezer, make sure it is on a flat surface and not tilted at an angle. If possible, place it towards the back of your freezer where temperatures are more consistent.

Once frozen, carefully twist or flex your plastic ice cube tray to loosen and release each individual cube. For extra stubborn cubes, run warm water over the bottom of the tray for a few seconds to help release them easily.

By following these simple tips for setting up your plastic ice cube trays, you’ll have perfectly shaped and easy-to-release ice cubes every time!

Read more:  Best Aroeve Hepa Air Purifier Consumer Reports


FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions) are common when it comes to buying products such as plastic ice cube trays. Here are some commonly asked questions about plastic ice cube trays and their respective answers.

Q: How many cubes can a typical plastic ice cube tray hold?
A: Most plastic ice cube trays can hold up to 12-16 cubes each.

Q: Can I use my plastic ice cube tray for more than just making ice?
A: Yes, some people use them for freezing baby food, herbs or even leftover sauce!

Q: Are there any tricks to getting the cubes out of the tray without breaking them?
A: Try running warm water over the bottom of the tray or gently twisting it back and forth until they loosen up.

Q: Do all plastic ice cube trays come with lids?
A: No, not all do. However, if you want to prevent spills while carrying your filled tray from sink to freezer, look for models that include an accompanying lid.

Q: Can I put my silicone/plastic/steel/aluminum/etc. ice cube tray in the dishwasher?
A: It depends on the manufacturer’s instructions. Always read cleaning recommendations before using any new product in your dishwasher.

Hopefully these FAQs have answered some of your burning questions surrounding this essential kitchen item!


After considering the different types of plastic ice cube trays, factors to consider before buying them, benefits and drawbacks of using them, common mistakes when using them, as well as installation and maintenance tips, it is clear that plastic ice cube trays are a great way to keep your drinks cool.

When shopping for the best plastic ice cube tray that suits your needs, it is essential to look out for its features such as size and shape options. Also take into consideration how easy they are to clean or if they can be washed in a dishwasher. The durability of the material used should also be considered so you don’t end up with flimsy trays that break easily.

With proper care and regular cleaning, you can enjoy using your plastic ice cube trays for an extended period without any issues. If you’re looking forward to having cold drinks all year round without worrying about melting ice cubes diluting your drink taste or quality then investing in one of these trays would come in handy.

Finding the right type of plastic ice cube tray doesn’t have to be challenging; by following our guide on what features matter most when selecting one will help make choosing much more manageable. A great-quality tray will give you years of hassle-free use while keeping those beverages icy cold!

Read more:  Best Hexclad Frying Pans Consumer Report
Rate this post