Best Cookie Sheets Consumer Reports

Best Cookie Sheets Consumer Reports

Whether you are a professional chef or an amateur baker, having the best cookie sheets is key to making perfect cookies. Different materials and designs can affect how your cookies turn out, so it is important to do your research before investing in a set of cookie sheets. In this blog post, we will compare some of the best options on the market and help you choose the perfect set for your needs. So whether you are looking for a durable sheet that will last through many batches of cookies, or a versatile option that can be used for baking other items as well, read on to find out more about the best cookie sheets available today.

Top 10 Best Cookie Sheets

*Note: Score is based on our AI score (Editor’s choice and rating).

What are cookie sheets?

Cookie sheets are baking pans with a flat surface and slightly raised edges. They are commonly used to bake cookies and other baked goods, such as biscuits, rolls, pastries, pies, and flatbreads. Cookie sheets come in various sizes and materials including aluminum, stainless steel, non-stick coated metal or silicone. The choice of material is largely determined by personal preference and usage; for example non-stick coated cookie sheets may be preferable for delicate items that might otherwise stick to the pan. Some cookie sheets have a dull (non-reflective) finish which helps to prevent overbrowning. Proper use of cookie sheets involves preheating them before adding the ingredients; this helps ensure even cooking throughout the entire item being baked.

Read more:  Best Smartliner Floor Mats Consumer Reports

Factors to consider before buying cookie sheets:


It’s important to purchase a cookie sheet that is made of high-quality material such as stainless steel, aluminum or anodized steel. These materials are not only durable and long-lasting, but they also heat evenly and won’t warp when exposed to hot temperatures in the oven.


An oversized cookie sheet will take up more space in your kitchen, so it’s important to choose the right size for your baking needs. Consider the types of cookies you’re making and how many batches you’ll need to bake each time before deciding on a particular size of cookie sheet.

Nonstick coating:

Many manufacturers offer nonstick coatings for their cookie sheets which make removing baked goods from the pan much easier. However, it’s important to consider how often you’ll need to replace these coatings and whether they are safe for food consumption when making your choice.


Cookie sheets can range from very inexpensive to quite costly depending on the type of material and features included. Consider your budget before choosing a particular model so that you don’t end up spending more than you can afford.

Ease of cleaning:

Easy-to-clean cookie sheets are always preferable since they help make baking much less of a hassle and save time in the kitchen. Look for models with removable or nonstick parts that can be washed quickly and easily after each use.


Some cookie sheets are more versatile than others, allowing you to use them for other baking tasks such as roasting vegetables or reheating frozen foods. If you enjoy experimenting with different recipes in the kitchen, look for a model that can be used for various purposes.

Read more:  Best Sleep Philosophy Flannel Sheets Consumer Report

Heat conduction:

Good heat conduction is an important factor when choosing a cookie sheet because it ensures even cooking and prevents burning on the edges of your baked goods. Aluminum and stainless steel are generally considered to be the best materials for conducting heat evenly throughout the entire surface of the pan.


A warranty is always a good idea when purchasing any type of kitchen appliance or tool, including cookie sheets. Look for models with long-term warranties to ensure that you’re covered if any unexpected issues arise with your purchase.

Benefits of cookie sheets

Cookie sheets are great for cooking and baking, but they are also helpful in other ways. Here are some of the benefits of cookie sheets:

-Protect your oven: If you’re going to be cooking something that will burn quickly or easily, like bacon or toast, it’s a good idea to line your pan with foil. This keeps food from sticking and makes cleanup easier.

-Keep food warm: If you want to keep food warm for a long time, use a cookie sheet instead of a plate or bowl. It will keep the heat in better than other containers would!

-Make cookies! Of course, most people use cookie sheets for baking cookies, but they can also be used for baking meatballs or other small treats.

-Use as trivets: If you have hot pans on your stovetop and don’t have trivets handy, use a cookie sheet instead! You can put it right on top of the pan without worrying about damaging anything or getting burned by steam coming from under it—just make sure it won’t slide off when you move around those pans!

-Reheat food: Instead of using a microwave oven, use a cookie sheet to reheat food. It’s the perfect size for single servings and can help keep your food from getting soggy or overcooking quickly. With this method, you also get to enjoy the flavor and texture of freshly cooked foods!

Read more:  Best Momo Steering Wheels Consumer Reports

-Make sandwiches: If you’re in a hurry, you can make sandwiches on a cookie sheet. Just put some deli meats and cheeses on it, then top them with lettuce and tomatoes before folding it over. In no time at all, you’ll have delicious sandwiches ready to eat!

-Be creative: There are endless possibilities when it comes to using cookie sheets in the kitchen. Get creative and come up with your own recipes!

Pros and Cons of cookie sheets


  1. They are a great way to keep cookies, brownies, and other baked goods from sticking to the pan and burning.
  2. They can be used for more than just baking; they’re also great for freezing food or making bread crumbs (and more).
  3. They come in many shapes and sizes so you can find one that fits your needs best.
  4. They don’t take up much space in your cupboard or on your countertop when not in use, making them easy-to-store items that won’t clutter up your kitchen space.
  5. They are relatively inexpensive, so you can buy them without breaking the bank.


  1. Many cookie sheets have a nonstick coating that can wear off over time, causing them to be less effective at keeping food from sticking.
  2. The edges of some cookie sheets can be sharp and dangerous if not handled properly.
  3. If they’re not cleaned regularly and properly, oils and other residues can build up on the surface, which can cause food to stick more easily or burn quickly in the oven.
  4. They may warp when heated in the oven due to uneven heating, which affects how evenly your baked goods will cook and potentially ruin them completely.
  5. Some cookie sheets may not be oven-safe, so it’s important to check the manufacturer’s specifications before using them for baking.
  6. Some cookie sheets are made of materials that can react with acidic or high-sugar ingredients and leach toxins into your food, so you should always use a sheet that is safe for cooking.
Read more:  Best Nebo Flashlight Consumer Report

How to use cookie sheets?

Cookie sheets are the perfect way to make delicious cookies without having to worry about burning or uneven baking. We’re going to show you how to use cookie sheets, so that you can create the most delicious cookies ever!

First, preheat your oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Then, line your cookie sheet with parchment paper or a Silpat mat. If you’re using a Silpat mat, make sure your mat is clean and free of any debris before placing it on your cookie sheet.

Next, place your dough on the cookie sheet and spread it out evenly with an offset spatula or knife. If you’re making chocolate chip cookies, place them at least two inches apart from each other so they don’t bake into one big mass. For chewy cookies like oatmeal raisin or peanut butter cups, make sure they are no more than 1 inch apart from each other.

Once they’re all spread out evenly, bake them for 10 minutes at 350 degrees Fahrenheit and then rotate them 180 degrees so that both sides get equal browning time in the oven (if this is not possible due to size constraints of your cookie sheet). Bake for another 5-10 minutes until golden brown on both sides. Remove from the oven and allow them to cool on the cookie sheet before transferring them to a cooling rack. Enjoy your freshly baked cookies!

Common mistakes when using cookie sheets

  1. Using a cookie sheet for something other than baking cookies

While you may be tempted to use your cookie sheet for frying chicken or roasting vegetables, it’s not the best choice. If you’re going to use your cookie sheet for anything other than baking cookies, we recommend using aluminum foil instead—it’ll protect the pan and keep it in good shape for when you really need it.

  1. Failing to grease the pan

Greasing the pan is essential if you want to get clean-looking cookies without having them stick. Greasing the pan also helps with browning, so if you’re looking for golden-brown edges on your baked goods, make sure to grease your cookie sheets!

  1. Washing off excess grease
Read more:  Best Polypropylene Vegetable Chopper Consumer Reports

You may think that washing off excess grease will help keep your pan clean and shiny, but it actually causes more problems than it solves. When you wash off excess grease from a dirty pan, you’re actually spreading the dirt around and making it harder (and more time-consuming) for yourself later on when you try to clean it up again! Instead of cleaning off excess grease from your pans after each use, just let them sit until there’s enough buildup on them so that they don’t look dirty anymore—that way you won’t have to worry about spreading dirt around.

  1. Using old or damaged pans

Using old or damaged cookie sheets can make your cookies come out unevenly cooked, and they may even stick more. If you’re using a pan that’s been used many times before, the best thing to do is to season it with a layer of melted butter or oil before baking—this will make sure that your cookies don’t stick and your baked goods come out perfect every time!

  1. Not rotating the pans during baking

It’s important to rotate the pans every now and then during baking in order to ensure even cooking throughout all of your cookies. This is especially true if you have multiple racks in your oven—make sure to move the pans around so that each cookie is getting sufficient heat from all sides. This will help you avoid any burnt or uncooked patches on your cookies!

  1. Reusing parchment paper too many times

Finally, it’s important to keep in mind that parchment paper has a limited lifespan—after a certain number of uses, it can start to lose its non-stick properties and end up sticking to your baking sheets. To ensure evenly cooked (and non-stuck!) cookies, we recommend replacing your parchment paper after every few uses. Doing this will save you time and frustration later on!

Read more:  The Smallest Portable Generators Consumer Report


How many cookies can fit on a cookie sheet?

This really depends on the size of the cookie sheet and the size of the cookies. Generally, a standard-sized cookie sheet can hold around 12 to 24 average-sized cookies depending on how much space is between each cookie. If you are making larger or smaller cookies, you may be able to fit more or fewer onto one cookie sheet. It also helps if you line your cookie sheets with parchment paper as it will prevent sticking and give added support for thinner/larger cookies that might otherwise slide off the edge.

When should you replace cookie sheets?

When it comes to replacing your cookie sheets, there are a few signs that you should look out for. If you notice that the surface of the sheet is warped or discolored, this can be an indication that it needs to be replaced. Additionally, if the nonstick coating on your baking sheet has started to wear off over time or show visible signs of wear and tear, then it might be time to invest in a new one. Finally, if you’ve noticed any rust spots appearing on the metal surface of your cookie sheets – no matter how small – then these definitely need to be replaced immediately as they can easily contaminate food with rust particles.


It can be hard to determine which cookie sheet is the best for your needs. We’ve looked at a variety of sheets and found the five that we think are the best. Whether you need something that is easy to clean or you are looking for a durable sheet, we have you covered. If you are still unsure after reading this post, don’t worry! We have included a buyer’s guide so that you can find the perfect sheet for your home. Thanks for reading and happy baking!

Rate this post

Leave a Comment